Many dog owners in most households often deal with the agony of their dog disappearing any time of the day or night without their knowledge, which can be disturbing. To remedy that problem, you can invest in reliable shock collars for your furry friends. Purchasing the best proximity shock collar for dogs is one sure-fire way of ensuring that your pooch doesn’t get lost in the woods. In this detailed review of the top five proximity shock collars for dogs, you’ll learn everything there is to know about the features of these shock collars, plus an easy-to-follow buying guide on how to get yourself the best product.
Who Needs Proximity Shock Collar For Dogs?
Restraining a dog may sound like a bad idea to some dog owners, right? Does your best friend keep escaping from the house or yard? If that is the case, you should consider investing in an electric fence or a proximity shock collar. Shock collars are designed with specific yardage or footage that designate a comfortable safety zone for your dog. In other words, your furry friend can safely navigate through the comfort zone without being shocked.
Once your dog is properly trained to understand the extent of the comfort zone (a region within which he can’t be shocked), he’ll always follow the shock collar’s warning sounds and stay within the confines of your yard. Your pooch will never again reach the boundary of its territory. So, we took out our time to test and try a variety of proximity shock collars for different types of dog breeds and came up with the following top picks of the Best Proximity Shock Collars for Dogs on the market.
Top Five Proximity Shock Collar for Dogs
1. Best Overall: Pet Control HQ Dog Containment System
This Pet Control HQ system is perfect for dog owners looking for training aids. It’s an ideal invisible underground fence that allows you to train your dog with the help of a training remote. The entire kit contains:
- A collar receiver.
- A rechargeable remote control.
- 492 feet of wiring.
- A wall-mounted transmitter.
With this invisible fence, you can conveniently envelop your yard area and block off areas such as swimming pools and garden beds. The rechargeable remote control can meritoriously deter unwanted behaviors such as jumping and barking that some aggressive dogs tend to display.
Furthermore, the remote can control three additional dog collars if you have more than one dog. This is a flexible proximity shock collar for dogs that allows you to add extra wiring to cover up to 10 acres. This is one of the best shock collars for breaking bad habits in stubborn dogs.
- 1 Waterproof Remote Control
- Training Guide
- 1 wall-mounted transmitter
- 1 USB Dual Splitter Charging Cable with power adaptor
- 492 ft. of 20-gauge Electric Proximity Fence wire
- 50 training flags
- 1 test light to check the fence
- Rechargeable & waterproof adjustable dog collar
- Yardage of 10 acres
- Short & long metal contact points
- Tools and connectors
- Compatible with all dog sizes
2. Best Runner-Up: Extreme Dog Fence – Second Generation
This is a great invisible fence for guarding different breeds and sizes of dogs. The Extreme Dog Fence can cover a yard area of up to a third of an acre. However, you can buy additional wire to extend the coverage to up to 6 acres. The kit comes with waterproof splices, flags, 500 ft. of wire, and a transmitter.
You don’t have to worry about shocking your dog when he’s exercising in a pond or pool because the 10 ft. collar of this invisible fence is waterproof. You can purchase more collars for your other dogs if you own more than one dog.
- Waterproof Splices
- 1x Waterproof Collar
- Digital Transmitter w/ Power Supply
- 1x Set of Conductive Rubber Comfort Covers
- 100x Training Flags
- Yardage of ⅓ acre
- 1000′ of 20 Gauge Wire
- 1x 6v Collar Battery
- Compatible with large dogs
- 1x Set of Short and Long Contact Probes (5/8″, 7/8″)
3. Best for Ease of Installation: PetSafe Basic In-Ground Dog and Cat Fence
This is a basic in-ground invisible dog fence that can help you keep your pup in up to a third of an acre. Just like the other PetSafe products we tested, the kits come with various accessories, including a dog collar, an adjustable transmitter, 500 ft. of wire, flags, surge protector, and splices. Even though the kit has one dog collar, the collar has 4 adjustable levels of shock correction and s tone-only mode for correcting your dog every time he approaches the boundary. While the kit comes with everything that you’ll need to install the system and get started, it’s also modular.
That means you can purchase additional collars for your other dogs and extend the range to cover up to 5 acres by buying extra wiring. Any proximity shock collar for dogs that allows extending the yardage or footage range is a good bargain in the world of dog shock collars. Furthermore, its installation process is a quick DIY project that you can easily execute on a random weekend. The dog collar fits neck sizes of 6-26 inches and is thus suitable for dogs that are 6 months and older. Therefore, if your dog weighs 8 pounds or more, this is a great invisible fence to keep him within the designated yard range.
- Dimensions of 11.97 x 4.37 x 6.06 inches
- Weighs 4.84 Pounds
- Lithium Metal batteries required
- Compatible with dogs weighing 8 pounds or more
- Yardage of ⅓ acre
- Waterproof collar
- Static levels
4. Best for Stubborn Dogs: PetSafe Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence for Dogs/Cats
This PetSafe invisible fence comes with all the items (accessories) that you need to get started and customize the invisible underground fence to suit the size and age of your dog. The accessories you’ll get include flags, a surge protector, 500 feet of wire covering a third of an acre, an adjustable collar, and a transmitter.
This is a great product for homeowners with expansive properties. You don’t have to invest in several proximity shock collars to keep your dog in your yard. Moreover, the shock collar has several layers of warning capable of training large, stubborn dogs to stay within range.
For instance, you can employ the four levels of shock correction, a vibration, and the warning tone to ensure that the dog remains within range at all times. But, if you need some additional reinforcement, you can invest in extra collars depending on how stubborn your dog proves to behave.
- Test light tool
- Adjustable collar fits neck sizes 6-28 in
- Static levels
- Compatible with dogs weighing 8 pounds or more
- 500 feet of wire and 50 training flags
- Yardage of a ⅓ acre
- PetSafe® 9V alkaline battery
- Waterproof collar
5. Best Wireless Design: PetSafe Stay & Play Wireless Fence for Stubborn Dogs
If you’re looking for a wireless fence that is perfect for restraining a troublesome dog within a designated yard range, then this PetSafe Stay & Play Wireless Fence is a perfect choice. The whole kit includes 50 boundary flags, a wireless transmitter, and a rechargeable collar receiver.
The transmitter is protected from short-circuiting because it has a power adapter and will, therefore, serve you for several years. The invisible fence is capable of covering up to ¾ of an acre. Moreover, you can buy an additional transmitter if you want to expand the yardage range.
The kit is designed with 5 static correction levels that offer you a wide range of options to choose from depending on what works best for your best friend. The invisible fence allows static-free reentry if the dog leaves the safety zone. You can buy additional dog collars if you own more than one dog.
- Product manual
- Test light tool
- 50 training flags
- Wireless transmitter
- Yardage of ¾ of an acre
- Waterproof dog collar
- Dog collar charger
- Mounting bracket
- Short and long contact points
- Contact point wrench
- Compatible with dogs weighing 5 pounds and up
Buying Guide for Best Proximity Shock Collar for Dogs
Buying the proximity shock collars for your dog can be a daunting task but not an impossibility. Here is a detailed guide on how to go about grabbing yourself the best product.
What is a proximity shock collar for dogs?
In the world of dog shock collars, some dog owners have invested in the best dog shock collars for dogs that don’t require you to use a traditional fence to restrain your dog within a cage or crate. The proximity training collars for dogs are designed to keep the dog within a designated range without affecting the dog’s physical health.
The proximity shock collars for dogs come with specific yardage or footage, also referred to as a safety zone. In other words, the dog will be shocked every time he comes close to the boundary. If you train your dog properly, he’ll learn to stay within the safe range to avoid being shocked once he touches the boundary of its territory.
The Proximity Shock Collar Range
Good shock collars for dogs are designed to fit different boundary ranges. The specific range of the shock collar that you choose to purchase will mainly depend on the size of your yard or the designated area where you want your dog to be restrained. Therefore, it’s possible to get a dog shock collar that extends in a yard area of about 330 ft., or even up to two miles.
In other words, the range will depend on your personal preferences and the size of your compound. Many of the credible makers of these proximity shock collars for dogs provide different yardage ranges for their shock collars to suit the different customer needs. But, if you feel your dog needs more room, you can expand the boundary safety zone.
The Difference Between an Electric Fence and a Proximity Shock Collar
The biggest difference between the two is that an electric fence is visible, while a proximity shock collar for dogs is invisible. That means the latter is a central transmitter that is designed to create a wireless sphere boundary. The sphere can also be created using an underground wire, especially if your yard is oddly shaped and won’t fit the spherical shape. While an electrical fence shocks your dog when he touches the hot wire, a wireless fence triggers the shock collar to respond. The response will be through static correction (shock), light, beep, or a soft vibration.
Electric fences can be dangerous to other natural wildlife in your area or to children because they shock anything that touches the hot wire. Moreover, the fence can inconveniently obstruct your view of the neighborhood. A proximity shock collar is designed to shock your dog as a corrective measure every time the dog goes too close to the fence or tries to jump over it. While an electric fence will help your dog learn to stay within his confines, a proximity shock collar for dogs does the same thing but without the physical fence. Moreover, a proximity shock collar is more effective because it warns your dog before he is shocked.
Keeping Your Dog Safely in the Yard
With a proximity shock collar for dogs, you’ll be able to keep your dog safely within the yard or its designated area. In 1-3 weeks, you can use the shock collars to easily train your dog to stay within the yard. You should use the lowest setting possible in training your dog for the first few days as a simple trigger, not as a punishment for your furry friend.
Over time, your dog will get used to the clicker, grab his attention, and achieve the desired behavior, which is to back away from the boundary. Make sure you reward your dog every time he manages to back away from the boundary during the training sessions. Eventually, the dog will learn that backing away from the boundary is the right thing to do.
Advantages of Proximity Shock Collars
Using a proximity shock collar for dogs has several benefits compared to the other methods of restraining a dog’s movements. First, your dog will easily and safely learn where his boundaries are. If you clearly demarcate the edges of the boundaries with flags, training the dog becomes much easier; the dog will constantly be reminded of the boundary edges whenever he sees the flags or the small indicators you mount. Ultimately, your dog will learn to roam within the yard without the proximity shock collar.
Second, the proximity shock collar for dogs is much safer for children and other animals in the surrounding area than the electric fence we discussed above. However, you’ll need to experiment with different settings of the shock levels to ensure it’s comfortable for your dog.
That is to ensure your dog is not being punished but safeguarded. The shock should only be intense enough to make the dog retreat from the boundary edge. The proximity shock collar for dogs eliminates the need to invest in an electric fence that might harm your dog and children.
Disadvantages of Proximity Shock Collars
To some small dogs, using a proximity shock collar that is somewhat painful and considered a negative reinforcement. There are other painless methods of training your dog to stay within his designated confines. Think about how the shock might feel on you before you try it on your dog.
That is why some animal rights advocates argue that proximity shock collars for dogs are forms of animal abuse. These activists recommend that dog owners should try other forms of positive reinforcement tactics for training their dogs to stay within their boundaries.
So, if you don’t want your best friend to experience some electric shock as a corrective measure, then the proximity shock collar may not be a viable solution. Moreover, the mild electric shock that a proximity shock collar produces might not be enough for stubborn dogs or larger dog breeds.
How can I keep my dog away from a particular area?
There are a few viable methods of keeping your dog out of a particular area. Proximity shock collars have proven to be very effective for dog owners who want to keep their dogs out of an area. Remember, it’s vital to train your pooch to stay out of a specific area even when using these proximity shock collars. You need to employ certain positive reinforcement practices for the shock collars to work for your dog. While traditional fences might work magic, most large dogs are capable of jumping over fences and getting lost in the process.
How effective are wireless dog fences?
A wireless dog fence can be effective in keeping your dog within the yard or a designated region if you charge the collar and ensure the unit is plugged in properly. Interestingly, some dogs are very intelligent and can wear out the collar’s batteries and cross the boundary. Therefore, to ensure the wireless dog fence works perfectly for your dog, you may need to engage him in some additional training.
What is the cost of an effective proximity shock collar for dogs?
If you don’t have a traditional or wireless fence for keeping your dog in the yard, then a proximity shock collar for dogs is your best bet. The cost of the proximity shock collar will depend on the yardage covered and the brand you choose to work with. Affordable shock collars that are effective cost around $30. You might also find more pricey models that cost up to $250, depending on where you buy the item.
You don’t need to contact your vet whenever your furry friends stray away or go missing! Investing in a reliable proximity shock collar is one way of ensuring you know where he is every time of the day. If he is unwell and probably hiding somewhere in the homestead, then you can actually seek the input of your pet’s veterinarian. Otherwise, purchasing a comfortable shock collar for your dog is a prudent idea. If you’ve other ideas and suggestions about the best proximity shock collar for dogs, feel free to share your experiences in our comments section below.
Dr. Belinda Hawks earned her Doctor of Veterinary Medicine from Colorado State University in 2006 and has been practicing veterinary medicine since then. Dr. Belinda currently works as a passionate rancher and mixed animal veterinarian in a rural town in South Carolina. When not practicing veterinary medicine or writing, she spends her free time with her lovely husband and three kids (2 boys and a lovely girl) in South Carolina.